CO alarm sounding, or headaches and nausea when the heat runs? Get everyone outside and call 911. Don't run the furnace again until it's inspected.
What the heat exchanger does
Inside a gas furnace, the burner flames fire into a set of metal chambers or tubes, the heat exchanger. The hot combustion gases travel through the inside and out the flue, while the blower pushes house air across the outside. Heat passes through the metal, but the gases and your air never mix. High-efficiency (90%+) furnaces add a secondary heat exchanger that pulls out extra heat and produces condensate.
Why heat exchangers crack
Metal expands every time it heats and contracts every time it cools. Over thousands of cycles, stress concentrates at bends and seams. Several things speed up cracking:
- Overheating from restricted airflow: clogged filters, closed or blocked vents, undersized ducts or a weak blower
- Oversized furnaces that short cycle, adding more heat-up and cool-down stress per day
- Age: furnaces past 15–20 years
- Corrosion from condensate in high-efficiency units, or from chemical fumes drawn into the combustion air
Warning signs
- A carbon monoxide alarm, or flu-like symptoms that ease when you leave the house
- Soot around the burners or the front of the furnace
- A yellow, lazy or flickering flame instead of a steady blue one
- Flames that wave or roll when the blower starts, a strong indication of a breach
- Visible rust, holes or cracks during inspection
- A tripped rollout switch
How a crack should be verified
"Your heat exchanger is cracked" has been misused as a high-pressure sales line. A legitimate finding comes with evidence, and you're entitled to see it:
- Visual or camera inspection. Photos or video of the crack, hole or separated seam.
- Combustion analysis. CO levels in the flue and changes when the blower starts.
- Flame behavior. Disturbance when the blower kicks on.
- Ambient CO readings in the supply air and living space.
If another company found a crack and you'd like confirmation, we offer an independent second-opinion inspection.
Repair or replace?
Heat exchangers generally aren't welded or patched. The options are replacing the heat exchanger or replacing the furnace:
- Heat exchanger replacement can make sense on a newer furnace, especially if the part is covered by the manufacturer's warranty (often 20 years or limited lifetime). You'd still pay labor, which is substantial.
- Furnace replacement usually makes more sense on an older furnace, when labor alone approaches the cost of a new unit, or when the part isn't available.
Either way, the cause (often airflow) should be fixed so the new heat exchanger doesn't crack too. Compare options on our furnace replacement page.
Heat exchanger repair cost
| Item | Typical cost | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Heat exchanger inspection with camera | $150 – $300 | Includes CO and combustion testing |
| Replacement, part under warranty | $1,200 – $2,500 | Labor and materials only |
| Replacement, part not under warranty | $2,000 – $4,000+ | Often close to new furnace cost |
| New gas furnace (alternative) | $3,500 – $8,500+ | See furnace replacement |