For most Schertz homes replacing both the furnace and AC, a heat pump is efficient most of the winter and handles cooling too. A gas furnace gives hotter air and steady heat in hard freezes without relying on electric heat strips. A dual-fuel system combines the two: the heat pump on mild days, gas on the coldest.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Gas furnace (+ AC) | Heat pump |
|---|---|---|
| How it heats | Burns natural gas or propane | Moves heat from outdoor air; heat strips as backup |
| Air at the vents | Hotter (often 120°F+) | Warm (often 90–100°F), longer cycles |
| Mild-weather efficiency | Good | Excellent |
| Hard freeze | Strong, steady heat | Leans on heat strips; higher electric use |
| Cooling | Needs a separate AC | Built in |
| Typical lifespan | Furnace 15–20 yrs | 10–15 yrs (runs year-round) |
| Needs gas service | Yes | No |
| Combustion safety | Needs CO alarms and yearly checks | No combustion in the home |
Why heat pumps fit Schertz's climate
Schertz sits in IECC climate zone 2A: hot summers and short, mostly mild winters. Heat pumps are most efficient in exactly those conditions, often delivering two to three times more heat than the electricity they use. Since you need cooling for most of the year anyway, one system handles both.
The freeze question
As outdoor temperatures fall toward freezing and below, a heat pump's capacity and efficiency drop, and electric heat strips take over more of the work. That's fine for occasional cold mornings. In a multi-day hard freeze like Winter Storm Uri in 2021, heat strips use a lot of electricity at the same moment the grid is strained. A gas furnace keeps producing full heat, though it still needs electricity to run its blower and controls.
Dual fuel: the best of both
A dual-fuel system pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace instead of heat strips. The thermostat runs the heat pump on mild days and switches to gas below a set outdoor temperature. You get efficient heating most of the winter and strong gas heat in a freeze. It's a popular choice when replacing a furnace and AC together in homes that already have gas.
Which should you choose?
Choose a heat pump if…
You're replacing the AC too, want one system for heating and cooling, don't have gas or want to drop it, and your electrical panel has capacity.
Choose a gas furnace if…
Your AC is newer, you prefer hotter air from the vents, and you want the strongest freeze performance.
Choose dual fuel if…
You have gas, are replacing both systems, and want efficiency plus freeze resilience.
Not sure?
A load calculation and a look at your gas and electric rates will show which costs less to run in your home.
Already have a heat pump? Learn what AUX and EM heat mean so you're not surprised by a high bill. See em heat vs heat.